Walk-In Showers vs. Bathtubs: Which Adds More Value?

If you're planning a bathroom remodel in Bartow, Lakeland, or Winter Haven, you've probably faced this question: should you keep the bathtub or swap it for a sleek walk-in shower? It's a big decision—and one that affects not just your daily routine, but your home's resale value down the road. As a trusted Polk County contractor, we at Blair Construction and Cabinets help homeowners weigh the pros and cons every day. Here's what you need to know to make the right choice for your home and your family.

The Growing Popularity of Walk-In Showers

Walk-in showers have become a top choice for bathroom remodels across Polk County and beyond. The National Kitchen & Bath Association's 2025 Bath Trends Report confirmed that replacing a bathtub with a walk-in shower is one of the most popular bathroom upgrades homeowners are investing in right now . But what's driving this trend?

Why Homeowners Love Walk-In Showers

Modern, spa-like aesthetics – A walk-in shower with frameless glass, rainfall showerheads, and built-in benches creates a luxurious feel that transforms any bathroom into a personal retreat .

Better accessibility – Low or zero-threshold entries make showers safer and easier to use, especially for older adults or anyone planning to age in place. This is a big consideration for many Polk County homeowners .

Easier cleaning – In Florida's humid climate, reducing areas where mold and mildew can hide is a real benefit. Fewer grout lines and no shower curtain or door track to scrub make maintenance simpler .

Water efficiency – A typical shower uses about 17 gallons of water, compared to 30+ gallons for a bath. That adds up over time .

For busy families and professionals in Lakeland and Winter Haven, the convenience and modern look of a walk-in shower are hard to beat.

Why You Should Consider Keeping a Bathtub

Despite the popularity of walk-in showers, experts agree that bathtubs aren't going anywhere—and for good reason. Glenn Cotton, president of Bath Fitter, puts it plainly: "Bathtubs aren't going anywhere. They still play a major role in both everyday living and long-term resale value" .

The Resale Value Factor

This is where the conversation gets important for homeowners considering a bathroom remodel. Real estate professionals consistently recommend keeping at least one bathtub in your home.

At least one tub is expected – Most buyers anticipate a bathtub in a home, especially in family-oriented neighborhoods throughout Bartow, Lakeland, and Winter Haven .

No tub can narrow your buyer pool – Removing every tub from your home could alienate up to 40% of potential buyers, according to some real estate professionals . Homes without a bathtub may also take longer to sell .

Family needs matter – If you have young children or pets, a tub makes bath time and pet washing infinitely easier. This is a practical consideration that many buyers prioritize .

As one real estate agent noted: "I have had clients turn to me after we've done a walk-through of a lovely home and say, 'Where's the tub? Where am I going to wash the kids? Where am I going to wash the dog?'" 

The Wellness Appeal of Bathtubs

Beyond resale, bathtubs serve a wellness purpose that many homeowners value. Freestanding tubs have become status symbols in luxury bathroom renovations, offering a place to soak, unwind, and de-stress after a long Florida day . If you prioritize self-care, a tub is a worthwhile investment for your own enjoyment.

Walk-In Shower vs. Bathtub: Which Adds More Home Value?

The short answer? Both can add value, but the safest choice is to have at least one bathtub in your home.

Here's why:

  • Walk-in showers are trendy and desirable, particularly for master bathrooms. They appeal to buyers looking for modern, accessible spaces . In urban or smaller homes, they can also save valuable square footage .

  • Bathtubs remain essential for families with young children and pets. If you remove the only bathtub in your home, you risk narrowing your buyer pool and potentially reducing your home's market value .

  • The best of both worlds – If you have two or more bathrooms, converting at least one to a walk-in shower is a smart move that adds both function and appeal. But keeping at least one tub preserves your home's broad market appeal .

Cost Considerations for Your Polk County Bathroom Remodel

Budget naturally plays a role in this decision. Here are some general cost ranges to keep in mind:

Project Type Estimated Cost Range
Basic tub-to-shower conversion $3,000 – $8,000+
Standard bathtub replacement $200 – $800 (basic)
Freestanding tub installation $2,000 – $7,000+
Full custom walk-in shower $12,000 – $25,000+

Sources: Angi, NYCO Renovations, Alliance Construction 

Keep in mind that custom features—like premium tile, multiple showerheads, and glass enclosures—can significantly increase costs. A licensed Polk County contractor can give you an accurate estimate after evaluating your existing layout and plumbing.

What's Right for Your Bartow, Lakeland, or Winter Haven Home?

Ultimately, the decision comes down to your household, lifestyle, and long-term plans:

  • If you have young children or pets – Keep at least one bathtub. It's practical for daily routines and important for resale.

  • If you're planning to age in place – A walk-in shower with accessibility features is a smart investment.

  • If you have two or more bathrooms – Convert one bathroom to a walk-in shower, but keep a tub in the other.

  • If your home has only one bathroom – Keep the tub or install a tub-shower combination to maintain resale appeal.

Your Trusted Polk County Bathroom Remodeling Partner

At Blair Construction and Cabinets, we help homeowners in Bartow, Lakeland, Winter Haven, and all of Polk County make informed decisions about their bathroom remodels. We specialize in:

  • Residential and commercial remodeling

  • Kitchen and bath renovations

  • Custom cabinets built for Florida's humidity

  • Flooring, drywall, and painting

We understand our local market, our climate, and what truly adds value to your home. And we're committed to clear communication, quality craftsmanship, and a smooth remodeling experience.

Ready to Transform Your Bathroom?

Whether you're dreaming of a spa-like walk-in shower or want to preserve that classic soaking tub, we'll help you choose the best option for your home and your budget.

Contact Blair Construction and Cabinets today!

📞 Call us at 863-224-4141
🌐 Visit www.blaircc.com and view our cabinet gallery
📍 Serving Bartow, Lakeland, Winter Haven, and all of Polk County

Let's schedule a consultation and start planning your dream bathroom.

Blair Construction and Cabinets – Excellence in Every Detail.